Last Updated: 13 November 2026
Almost every large organisation now runs a mentoring program. Yet according to Harvard Business Review, only about 37% of professionals actually benefit from mentoring programs. The gap between having a program and running a good one is where most of the value is won or lost.
At Brancher, we've helped government departments, member associations and national employers design, match and measure mentoring programs across Australia. This guide distils what we've seen work, stage by stage, with real results from our clients.
Key Takeaways
- Effective mentoring programs start with a business problem, not a program.
- Matching on values, personality and goals drives satisfaction more than matching on seniority.
- Structure and regular nudges keep pairs meeting; early intervention rescues stalled pairs.
- Measure outcomes the business cares about, such as retention, promotion and engagement, and report them.
What are Mentoring Best Practices?
Mentoring best practices are proven principles for designing, running and measuring mentoring so that it delivers results for participants and the organisation. They work at two levels: program practices for HR and L&D teams (goals, matching, training, measurement) and relationship practices for mentors and mentees (expectations, communication, feedback).
Signs Your Mentoring Program Needs a Reset
If any of these sound familiar, the practices below will help:
- Leaders see mentoring as a "nice to have" with no link to business goals
- Sign-ups are low, or mentors are hard to find
- Pairs report poor fit, or stop meeting after the first month
- Nobody can say what the program has achieved
- Matching and follow-ups eat hours of admin time
Mentoring Best Practices at a Glance
| Stage | Best practice | What to track |
|---|---|---|
| Design | 1. Start with a business problem | Agreed program KPIs |
| Design | 2. Secure an executive sponsor | Sponsor involvement |
| Design | 3. Choose the right format and cadence | Participation rate |
| Match | 4. Match on values, personality and goals | Match satisfaction |
| Match | 5. Give participants a say in matching | Rematch rate |
| Launch | 6. Recruit and promote deliberately | Sign-ups vs target |
| Launch | 7. Train mentors and mentees | Training completion |
| Launch | 8. Design for inclusion and accessibility | Participation by group |
| Run | 9. Set expectations in the first meeting | Goals set per pair |
| Run | 10. Keep momentum with structure | Meetings per pair |
| Run | 11. Intervene early when pairs stall | Pairs at risk |
| Measure | 12. Measure outcomes and close the loop | Retention, promotion, NPS |
Stage 1: Design
1. Start with a business problem, not a program
The strongest programs answer a specific question: Why are we losing early-career talent? How do we build our leadership pipeline? How do we keep women in trades? Turn the answer into SMART goals before anyone is matched, so you know what success looks like and can prove it later. See our guide to setting mentoring goals.
Brancher in practice: South Australia's Department of Infrastructure and Transport (DIT) had plenty of informal mentoring across its 2,200+ workforce but no structure. Together we designed two six-month programs aligned to four development streams, turning ad hoc connections into a strategic workforce asset. Read the DIT case study.
2. Secure an executive sponsor
Senior sponsorship signals that mentoring matters, unlocks budget and draws in mentors. In our customer roundtables for our public sector mentoring white paper, executive support came up as a critical success factor. Ask your sponsor to launch the program, mentor in it and hear the results.
"The platform is absolutely fantastic." Sarah Vandersee, DDG Corporate, Queensland Government Department of Tourism and Sport
3. Choose the right format and cadence
Match the format to the goal:
| Format | Best for |
|---|---|
| One-to-one | Career development, leadership growth |
| Group or circles | Scaling access, breaking down silos |
| Peer | Onboarding, belonging |
| Reverse | Digital skills, inclusion awareness |
| Always-on | Members or staff who need mentoring on their own timeline |
| Cohort-based | Time-bound goals, structured learning |
Brancher in practice: The Asset Management Council (AMC) ran a rigid, once-a-year program that members struggled to fit around. Moving to an always-on mentoring community with science-based matching and bite-sized training delivered a 91% mentee NPS and 100% mentor return intent. Read the AMC case study.
Stage 2: Match
4. Match on values, personality and goals
Matching is where outcomes are largely decided. As an organisational psychologist, I've seen that pairing people only on job title or seniority often produces polite but shallow relationships. Shared values and complementary goals build the trust that makes honest feedback possible.
Brancher in practice: Women in Media scaled a state pilot into a national program of 183 matched pairs across five-plus cohorts, with 100% match satisfaction in the national cohort. Read the Women in Media case study.
"I think it did a really great job of pairing us." Karen Milliner, mentor, Women in Media program [VERIFY permission to reuse]
5. Give participants a say in matching
Admin-led matching suits targeted programs; self-matching suits large, mature communities. Many programs blend both: an algorithm suggests matches and participants choose. Read more about choosing a matching approach.
Brancher in practice: Fletcher Building's small L&OD team found manual matching had become a bottleneck for its high-potential talent program. Switching to self-directed matching, built-in training and automated nudges kept pairs engaged: 80% of pairs met six or more times. Read the Fletcher Building case study.
Stage 3: Launch
6. Recruit and promote deliberately
Open registration weeks before launch, use multiple channels, and share stories from past participants. Mentor supply is usually the constraint, so make the ask personal and spell out what mentors gain. See how to recruit mentors and mentees.
Brancher in practice: Manufacturing Skills Queensland's Women in Trades program matched 129 mentees with 91 mentors across five cohorts, comfortably exceeding its contracted target. Read the MSQ case study.
7. Train mentors and mentees before they meet
Many people feel unsure what mentoring involves. Short training on active listening, goal setting, giving feedback and boundaries gives both sides the confidence to start well.
Brancher in practice: The Australasian Corrosion Association's four-month pilot combined smart matching with structured learning. Results: 100% match satisfaction, a 100% recommendation rate, and 42% of participants expecting a promotion. Read the ACA case study.
8. Design for inclusion and accessibility
Left to chance, people tend to mentor people like themselves. Structured programs counter this: Harvard Business Review research found that, on average, mentoring programs boosted management representation among Black, Hispanic, and Asian-American women, and Hispanic and Asian-American men, by 9% to 24%. Inclusion also means reducing power imbalances (for example, letting mentees set the agenda) and making the program accessible to everyone.
Brancher in practice: Women With Disabilities Australia (WWDA) needed a national program a small team could run. An online-first model with values-based matching, screen reader compatibility, Easy Read content and captioned sessions supported around 60 pairs over two years, and was showcased at the United Nations Commission on the Status of Women. Read the WWDA case study.
Stage 4: Run
9. Set expectations in the first meeting
The first meeting should cover goals, meeting frequency, preferred communication and confidentiality. A simple mentoring agreement captures this. Brancher's Goals Module helps pairs set SMART goals and track progress.

10. Keep momentum with structure and nudges
Busy calendars are the biggest threat to mentoring. Suggested agendas, discussion prompts and automated reminders keep pairs meeting. Most programs work well with monthly meetings, moving to fortnightly for onboarding or short programs.
11. Intervene early when pairs stall
Not every match will work, and that's normal. Short check-in surveys after meetings flag pairs who have stopped meeting or rate their fit poorly. Reach out quickly and rematch if needed, before a disappointing experience turns into disengagement.
"100% of mentees reported they were more engaged in their role as a result of the program." Whitney Lewis, Learning and Development Consultant, Government of South Australia
Stage 5: Measure and Improve
12. Measure outcomes, close the loop and celebrate wins
Track leading indicators during the program (sign-ups, match satisfaction, meetings held, goals set) and lagging indicators afterwards (retention, promotion, engagement, internal mobility). Report results to your sponsor, act on feedback for the next intake, and celebrate participants' achievements.
Brancher in practice: Women in Media cut program administration by 80% and reached 92% retention. Estimate the value of your own program with our ROI calculator.
Best Practices for Mentors and Mentees
For mentors
- Listen first; hold back advice until you understand the mentee's goals
- Ask open questions rather than giving answers
- Share mistakes as well as successes
- Give honest, kind feedback
- Respect confidentiality
For mentees
- Own the relationship: schedule meetings and set the agenda
- Arrive with a specific question or goal
- Act on advice and report back
- Ask for feedback, not just reassurance
More in our mentoring tips for mentees.
Mentoring Program Examples at a Glance
| Organisation | Program | Headline result |
|---|---|---|
| Women in Media | National program for women in media | 183 pairs, 100% match satisfaction, 92% retention |
| Asset Management Council | Always-on member mentoring | 91% mentee NPS |
| Australasian Corrosion Association | Early-career pilot | 42% expect promotion |
| Fletcher Building | High-potential talent | 80% of pairs met 6+ times |
| Manufacturing Skills Queensland | Women in Trades | 129 mentees, 91 mentors |
| WWDA | Accessible national program | ~60 pairs, UN showcase |
Browse all Brancher case studies.
Frequently Asked Questions
How often should mentors and mentees meet?
Monthly is a good baseline. Meet fortnightly for onboarding or short programs.
How long should a mentoring program run?
Most structured programs run four to twelve months. Six months is common, as in our DIT and NRMRQ programs. Always-on programs let pairs set their own timeline.
What makes a mentoring program successful?
Clear business goals, good matching, trained participants, regular structure and measured outcomes.
How do you measure mentoring success?
Combine participation data (match satisfaction, meetings held, goals achieved) with business outcomes such as retention, promotion and engagement.
How many mentees should one mentor have?
One or two is ideal for one-to-one mentoring. Group mentoring and circles let one mentor support more people.
Make Mentoring Work for Your Organisation
Great mentoring isn't luck. It's the result of clear goals, thoughtful matching, real structure and honest measurement. Whether you're launching your first program or scaling an existing one, talk to our team or book a demo.
About the Author
Holly Brailsford is an organisational psychologist and the Co-founder and CEO of Brancher. She has experience designing mentoring and development programs for government, industry and member organisations.
References
- Harvard Business Review, [Why Mentoring Programs Fail - and How to Make Them Worthwhile", December 2024]
- Dobbin, F. & Kalev, A. (2016). "Why Diversity Programs Fail." Harvard Business Review.
- Brancher client case studies, results reported by program administrators via the Brancher platform.

